Aisquith Pastors
| Rev. Robert Dunlap |
October 10, 1844 |
| Rev. Thomas Warren |
December 11, 1851 |
| Rev. David Carnahan |
April 27, 1854 |
| Rev. Joseph Clair Stuckell |
November 20, 1862 |
| Rev. James S. Ramsey |
February 25, 1867 |
| Rev. James E. Lapsky |
Called, but died before being installed |
| Rev. Stephen D. Noyes |
May 20, 1873 |
| Rev. George D. Buchanan |
November 13, 1879 |
| Rev. Silas Davenport |
October 16, 1883 |
| Rev. J. Addison Smith |
March 1, 1889 |
| Rev. David T. Neily |
March 25, 1901 |
| Rev. James M. Wallace |
October 9, 1914 |
| Rev. Louis Hoffman |
December 1, 1939 |
| Rev. Irvin R. Morris |
May 15, 1941 |
| Rev. Andrew Newcomer, Jr. |
1945 |
| Rev. Edward G. Conrad |
May 17, 1948 |
| Rev. Stuart G. Wysham |
October 14, 1954 |
| Rev. George R. Barnitt |
November 5, 1961 |
| Rev. Thomas E. Graham |
September 21, 1969 |
| Rev. Thomas L. Wenger (assistant) |
March 27, 1983 |
| Rev. James P. Raun (assistant) |
October 13, 1985 |
| Rev. Dr. D. Ralph Davis |
August 7, 1988 |
| Rev. Timothy J. McQuitty (assistant) |
March 22, 1992 |
| Rev. Robert E. Bell |
December 18, 1994 |
| Rev. John E. Ceselsky (assistant) |
Febgruary 27, 2000 |
|